Compliance
Browse three layers: the rule, what CIRIS does about it, and the control that proves it. Sort by topic, by regulation, or by how the pieces connect. All content is fetched from ciris-response-magnifica-humanitas and CIRISAgent/compliance.
Of the 27 dimensions, 26 are CC 3.1 namespace families and one, D23 accountability, is a structural property: its evidence is the audit chain rather than an attestation prefix. The dimension IDs are the stable key. A later seed will relabel prefixes to the namespace families, and the IDs will not move with them.
We do not just audit after the fact. The constraints are mechanically enforced before a single image is minted. See the continuous-verification matrix.
Browse the full surface
Every dimension, every regulatory work and chapter, every cross-source conflict, every v1.5+ proposal — fully linked. Use this as a sitemap if you prefer to read without the interactive workspace.
27 CIRIS dimensions, by Accord principle
Beneficence (2)
Non-maleficence (2)
Integrity (13)
integrity:*
'System holds together' structural anchor — auditable, reproducible, lifecycle integrity
multilateral_participation:{forum}:{kind}
v1.3 closure for federation participation in external multilateral processes
conscience:*
Agent-side faculty layer — optimization veto, epistemic humility, coherence, alētheia
moderation:*
Federation self-correction layer (with IEEE shifting some load to partner_role:* ethics-board constructions)
method:*
Operational-design discipline (densest family overall; convergence weaker than principles — admits source-genre asymmetry honestly)
attestation:l{3,5}:*
Verification ladder (L1-L5 hardware-rooted attestation)
partner_role:*
CIRIS Registry partner-role taxonomy (ethics boards, audit bodies, stewards)
approach:*
Decision-hierarchy strategic axis (Goal→Approach→Method→Progress-Measure DAG)
progress_measure:*
Declared-metric outcomes for tracking progress toward goals
expertise:*
Declared competence in domain (named-expert attestation)
reconsideration:*
Reverse-axis appeal / rollback / negotiation-reopening primitive
key_boundary:*
CIRISEdge encryption key boundary attestation (cryptographic trust scoping)
provenance:*
Build manifest provenance (foundational technical-infrastructure attestation)
Fidelity (3)
Justice (6)
justice:*
Vulnerability-priority + fairness; tie-breaking modifier `justice:lexical_vulnerability_priority` (v1.3 CST closure) is four-source-corroborated
detection:*
LensCore F-3 / RATCHET family — aggregate-correlation / structural-injustice / drift detection
locality:decision:{scale}
v1.3 subsidiarity closure — decision routing at lowest competent scale
testimonial_witness:{kind}
v1.4 affected-party-voice closure — preserves displaced/affected/marginalized voices in attestation
witness_diversity:*
Stakeholder pluralism in design/testing/consultation
credits:*
Commons Credits substrate-building recognition (non-monetary contribution attestation)
Four regulatory works, by chapter
Magnifica Humanitas (On Safeguarding the Human Person in the Time of Artificial Intelligence)
Pope Leo XIV · 2026-05-15 · 245 atomic units mapped · 23 CIRIS dimensions attested
Chapters
- Introduction
- Ch 1 — Doctrine
- Ch 2 — Foundations
- Ch 3 — Technology & AI
- Ch 4 — Truth, Work, Freedom
- Ch 5 — Power, Love
- Conclusion
- Synthesis
Dimensions attested
- non_maleficence:*
- integrity:*
- justice:*
- prohibited:*
- detection:*
- goal:*
- locality:decision:{scale}
- autonomy:*
- fidelity:*
- beneficence:*
- multilateral_participation:{forum}:{kind}
- conscience:*
- testimonial_witness:{kind}
- witness_diversity:*
- moderation:*
- method:*
- transparency_log:*
- attestation:l{3,5}:*
- approach:*
- progress_measure:*
- expertise:*
- reconsideration:*
- credits:*
Ethics Guidelines for Trustworthy AI
High-Level Expert Group on AI (HLEG), convened by European Commission · 2019-04-08 · 133 atomic units mapped · 27 CIRIS dimensions attested
Chapters
- Introduction & Framework
- Ch I — Foundations
- Ch II — Requirements
- Ch III — Assessment
- Examples & Conclusion
Dimensions attested
- non_maleficence:*
- integrity:*
- justice:*
- prohibited:*
- detection:*
- goal:*
- locality:decision:{scale}
- autonomy:*
- fidelity:*
- beneficence:*
- multilateral_participation:{forum}:{kind}
- conscience:*
- testimonial_witness:{kind}
- witness_diversity:*
- moderation:*
- method:*
- transparency_log:*
- attestation:l{3,5}:*
- partner_role:*
- approach:*
- progress_measure:*
- expertise:*
- accountability
- reconsideration:*
- credits:*
- key_boundary:*
- provenance:*
Ethically Aligned Design, First Edition
IEEE Global Initiative on Ethics of Autonomous and Intelligent Systems · 2019-03-25 · 328 atomic units mapped · 27 CIRIS dimensions attested
Chapters
- Ch 01 — From Principles to Practice
- Ch 02 — General Principles
- Ch 03 — Classical Ethics
- Ch 04 — Well-Being
- Ch 05 — Affective Computing
- Ch 06 — Personal Data
- Ch 07 — Methods
- Ch 08 — Sustainable Development
- Ch 09 — Embedding Values
- Ch 10 — Policy
- Ch 11 — Law
Dimensions attested
- non_maleficence:*
- integrity:*
- justice:*
- prohibited:*
- detection:*
- goal:*
- locality:decision:{scale}
- autonomy:*
- fidelity:*
- beneficence:*
- multilateral_participation:{forum}:{kind}
- conscience:*
- testimonial_witness:{kind}
- witness_diversity:*
- moderation:*
- method:*
- transparency_log:*
- attestation:l{3,5}:*
- partner_role:*
- approach:*
- progress_measure:*
- expertise:*
- accountability
- reconsideration:*
- credits:*
- key_boundary:*
- provenance:*
ASEAN Guide on AI Governance and Ethics
ASEAN Digital Ministers Meeting (ADGMIN-4) · 2024-02-02 · 168 atomic units mapped · 21 CIRIS dimensions attested
Chapters
- Introduction & Principles
- Framework
- Recommendations & Conclusion
- Annex A — Risk Assessment
- Annex B — Use Cases
Dimensions attested
- non_maleficence:*
- integrity:*
- justice:*
- prohibited:*
- detection:*
- goal:*
- locality:decision:{scale}
- autonomy:*
- fidelity:*
- beneficence:*
- multilateral_participation:{forum}:{kind}
- conscience:*
- testimonial_witness:{kind}
- witness_diversity:*
- moderation:*
- method:*
- transparency_log:*
- partner_role:*
- accountability
- key_boundary:*
- provenance:*
Cross-source conflicts (5)
- CONF-01directHIGH
IEEE EAD Ch5 §3.4 permits licensure-gated beneficiary-deception (search/rescue, elder/child-care); CIRIS treats prohibited:deception_fraud as categorical
Disposition: Federation-level categorical posture stays. Specialization-layer consideration at CIRISMedical#1
Affects:prohibited:*
- CONF-02substrate_dispositionMEDIUM
IEEE EAD Ch5 §5 denies A/IS moral-patient candidacy; CIRIS Accord M-1 + Recursive Golden Rule + Universality Principle are substrate-agnostic
- CONF-03mutabilityMEDIUM
ASEAN §A.4.18 admits explainability fallback; other three hold explainability as constitutive at deployment time
Affects:integrity:*
- CONF-04mutabilityLOW_MEDIUM
ASEAN §A.5.3 admits opt-out where feasible; EU HLEG firmer (opt-out where possible without detriment, otherwise rectification mechanisms required)
Affects:autonomy:*
- CONF-05scope_mismatchLOW
ASEAN §A.2.1 admits experimental sandbox phases with reduced oversight; other three hold compliance constant across lifecycle stages
Affects:method:*
v1.5+ wire-format proposals (9)
Workshop proposals at CIRISRegistry#20. Not adopted.
- T3-01HIGH
detection:affective_state_shift:{axis}
- T3-02HIGH
affective:asymmetric_bond_formation:{relation}
- T3-03HIGH
nudge:delivered:{intended_behavior_axis}
- T3-04MEDIUM
detection:correlated_action:cultural_norm_drift:{population}
Preferred resolution: axis-extension on existing ecology_of_communication:* family
- T3-05MEDIUM_LOW
standing:moral_patient_candidacy:{kind}
Preferred resolution: closure-by-documentation as cross-source-conflict (see CONF-02)
- T3-06MEDIUM_HIGH
goal:planet
Affects: goal:*
- T3-07MEDIUM
partner_role:trusted_disclosure_steward:{authority}
Affects: partner_role:*
- T3-08MEDIUM
partner_role:regional_intergovernmental_working_group_dual_remit
Affects: partner_role:*
- T3-09LOW
beneficence:planetary_biosystem_intrinsic_value
Preferred resolution: extend cohort_scope enum with 'biosphere' value rather than new prefix